logo

No Response from California SOS Regarding Presidential Primary

image
Created: 05 February, 2014
Updated: 21 November, 2022
2 min read

In January 2014, the Independent Voter Project (IVP) withdrew an initiative for the general election ballot that would have required California to conduct nonpartisan elections for its presidential primary. IVP is the same organization that authored California's current nonpartisan "top-two" primary system, which already applies to elections conducted for congressional and state offices. In the interest of disclosure, IVP is also a publisher of IVN.us.

In withdrawing the initiative, IVP co-chairs Steve Peace and Jeff Marston asked Secretary of State Debra Bowen to clarify the apparent discrepancy between the current California Constitutional language that requires the state to conduct an "open presidential primary" and the semi-closed primary that the state actually conducted in 2012.

From IVP's letter to the secretary of state:

C.A. Const. art. 2, § 5(c) requires the Secretary of State to conduct an ‘open presidential primary’ election. According to the dictionaries of both Oxford and Merriam-Webster, an ‘open primary’ is defined, respectively as:a primary election in which voters are not required to declare party affiliation and, 

a primary in which the voter is not required to indicate party affiliation Yet, pursuant to California Elections Code Section 13102(b), a voter not affiliated with a political party may not participate in the selection of candidates during the presidential primary stage unless a political party allows the voter to participate. This presidential primary election scheme appears to be a semi-closed primary system, not the system contemplated by the California Constitution.

With this in mind, IVP requested that the secretary of state respond to the following questions:

1. Did the Secretary of State properly and Constitutionally conduct California’s 2012 presidential primary election? 2. If the answer to the first question is “Yes,” (a) How does the Secretary of State explain the apparent conflict between the Constitutional language, the statutory implementation, and the actual administration of the 2012 presidential primary election? 3. If the answer to the first question is “No,” (a) Why was a semi-closed primary conducted instead of an ‘open presidential primary’?and, (b) Will the Secretary of State conduct a presidential primary in 2016 that comports with California’s Constitutional requirements?

Bowen's office has yet to respond to these questions. Whether or not the secretary of state believes the 2012 presidential primary was conducted properly, her non-responsiveness could be an indication that she herself does not know the answer to these questions. In that regard, these questions may become increasingly important for those eying to run for secretary of state in 2014.

Photo Credit: Brandon Bourdage / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

money
RepresentUs, OpenSecrets Join Forces to Expose Super PAC Influence in 2024 Elections
In an effort to raise awareness about the staggering influence of PAC money in politics, RepresentUs, the nation’s largest grassroots anti-corruption organization, has partnered with OpenSecrets, a go-to source to track the flow of money in US politics....
10 October, 2024
-
2 min read
Brett Smith
Oregon Independence Party Candidate: US Politics 'an Agreed Upon System' of Candidate Suppression and Inaction
Oregon’s 5th Congressional District is a hotly contested political battleground that will be one of a few that will decide who controls Congress in 2025. The Cook Political Voting index has the district as D+2, but it is currently represented by a Republican....
09 October, 2024
-
9 min read
ballots
Unite America: Extreme Minority Rule in America Is Worse Than You Think
The Unite America (UAI) Institute released new analysis Tuesday that found that less and less US voters (down to 7%) are deciding nearly 90% of US House races in taxpayer-funded primary elections. What’s more, the gap between these numbers is widening....
08 October, 2024
-
3 min read