logo

A Top-Four Primary is Better for California, FairVote Says

image
Author: Lucas Eaves
Created: 24 Jun, 2013
Updated: 14 Oct, 2022
3 min read

Last week, FairVote.org released a new policy paper, in which it presents a proposition to resolve the deficiencies of California's nonpartisan top-two primary.

FairVote is an advocate for reforming U.S. elections "to respect every vote and every voice in order to increase voter turnout, meaningful ballot choices and fair representation." In 2010, they

opposed Proposition 14, the initiative that created "top-two" in California, which the group believed had severe flaws.

After analyzing the effect of the top-two primaries in Washington between 2008-2012 and the California 2012 elections, some believe the new system did not reform the electoral system in the way people hoped it would.

However, respecting the choice of Californians, FairVote chose to research ways to improve the nonpartisan top-two primary rather that try to reverse back to the old system.

Their 2014 Policy Perspective on how to fix top-two in California is articulated around three main ideas:

1. Change top-two to a top-four primary system

One of the main criticisms of top-two is that it reduces the choice of voters to only two candidates in November and most, if not all, of the time it will be two candidates from the Republican  Party or Democratic Party, or even two candidates from the same major party.

In its policy paper, FairVote argues that the solution to this problem is to amend the current system to have the top-four candidates move on to the November ballot. This will not only give an opportunity to more candidates from minor parties to make it to the general election, but also increases the number of intraparty races.

Credit: Fair Vote

Top-four primary system

2. The November ballot becomes a ranked-choice system

The November election would be decided with ranked-choice voting. The voters will have the opportunity to rank up to three candidates on the ballot. Those rankings would simulate two runoff rounds:

More Choice for San Diego

  1. First eliminating the candidate in fourth place and then eliminating the candidate in third place
  2. To ensure the winner has majority support when matched against his or her top opponent.

This system is already being used for municipal elections in San Francisco and Oakland.

3. Improve the party labels on the ballot

Under the current system, party labels associated with a candidate on the ballot merely indicates a party preference and not a party endorsement. This system has been chosen to respect a previous Supreme Court decision that struck down California's blanket primary. However, data suggests that voters see candidates with a party label as the candidate for that party.

Super No Funding Time_ad2

FairVote believes the labeling system could be enhanced if the party or parties which endorsed a candidate were added after the candidate's name and party affiliation.

FairVote's policy paper offers many ideas to improve California's primary system, all of which have their benefits and their inconveniences. Ranked voting has not been without controversy in San Francisco and Oakland, especially regarding the complexity of the system for voters.

California's top-two system has only been used for one election cycle. It might be beneficial to wait a few more cycles before making any definitive conclusions on the effectiveness of the system and trying to change it again.

The full policy paper can be read here.

Latest articles

Judge sitting at a desk with their fingers interlocked. A scale and gavel appear on the desk.
Most Evanston Voters Said They Wanted Ranked Choice Voting, But Will They Get It?
In 2022, nearly 83% of voters in Evanston, Illinois, approved a city referendum to adopt ranked choice voting. The referendum stated that the first use of the new voting method would be during the city's consolidated elections in April 2025....
11 Dec, 2024
-
4 min read
silhouette of a hand putting a ballot in a box.
As Expected, Alaska Measure 2 Recount Didn't Change Anything
The recount in Alaska over Ballot Measure 2 is complete. The state's Republican Party requested it after voters rejected the initiative and chose to keep their nonpartisan election system by a narrow margin. But as predicted on IVN, this margin wasn't narrow enough for the results to change....
10 Dec, 2024
-
1 min read
businessman holding his hands to his face.
New Poll: Half of US Voters Say They Voted For 'Lesser of Two Evils' in 2024
Citizen Data polled US voters following the 2024 elections and found that nearly half (47%) said they cast their ballot, not for the candidate they supported the most, but for the candidate they determined was the 'lesser of two evils.'...
09 Dec, 2024
-
2 min read