California Supreme Court Decision Victory for Small Business

image
Created: 16 Apr, 2012
Updated: 13 Oct, 2022
1 min read

NFIB_logo

PRESS RELEASE

Sacramento, CA., April 16, 2012 — In a victory for employers, the California Supreme Court clarified a number of issues relating to an employer's obligations under California Labor Code § 512(a), which states that employers must "provide" meal and rest periods to employees. The court held that an employer must relieve an employee of all duty for a meal period, but is not obligated to ensure that the employee does no work. The lawsuit was filed by five employees of Chili's restaurant chain who claimed the restaurant illegally denied them meal and rest breaks.

In response to the decision, John Kabateck, NFIB/CA Executive Director, applauded the court's common-sense approach, which he said "relieves small employers of the near-impossible task of monitoring all employees during breaks to ensure that no work is performed."

The court also decided that if work does continue, the employer will not be liable for premium pay but will only have to pay for actual time worked if it “knew or reasonably should have known that the worker was working through the authorized meal period.”

Karen Harned,  executive director, National Federation of Independent Business Small Business Legal Center, said that "the court's finding on damages provides an important limitation that will help staunch the number of frivolous wage and hour claims filed by plaintiffs' attorneys."

The case is Brinker Restaurant Group v. Superior Court of San Diego. The NFIB Small Business Legal Center filed an amicus brief in the case.

Latest articles

United states map with red and blue stacks over each state.
Gallup: Americans More Likely to Rank Government Leadership as No. 1 Problem
The latest polling data from Gallup shows that the number one problem facing the US for most voters now is not the economy, it is not cost of living or inflation -- it is poor leadership in the government....
15 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
Oakland, CA
Oakland Votes in Pivotal Mayoral Election with Ranked Choice Voting at the Center
In a critical special election, Oakland voters are casting their ballots on April 15 to replace recalled Mayor Sheng Thao. The election will be decided using ranked choice voting (RCV) and determine who leads the city through 2027, as Oakland faces mounting challenges....
15 Apr, 2025
-
5 min read
US Capitol Building with American flag.
Parental Proxy Voting Effort in Congress Gives Independent Voters Hope
It’s a bipartisan effort. Independent voters are tired of division and Congress’s inability to achieve results. We rarely see a bipartisan effort in Congress today because, in many respects, we are not allowed to witness it....
15 Apr, 2025
-
6 min read