logo

Super Committee not acting like superheroes when it comes to solving debt crisis

image
Author: Alan Markow
Created: 17 November, 2011
Updated: 13 October, 2022
3 min read

Somebody call Superman.  The Justice League of America is about to fall on its fanny.  All right, I know Superman’s a member of the Justice League, but the point is that our superheroes are failing us – or at least the vaunted Congressional Super Committee appears to be on the verge of failing to meet its appointed duties. And it's on the verge of failing when the national debt has just passed the infamous $15 trillion mark.

According to The Washington Post, the Super Committee – officially the United States Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction -- has only days to come up with a budget agreement that will take trillions of dollars of red ink out of the nation’s budget outlook and prevent a series of crises precipitated by the need to approve higher debt ceilings every few months.

It seemed logical just under a year ago when another select committee – the bipartisan Simpson-Bowles National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility – recommended a combination of budget cuts and tax increases to meet this very need.  Its plan was highly praised because it took on the sacred cows of entitlement programs such as Social Security, Medicare and defense spending.  But neither the President nor Congressional leaders embraced the Commission’s report, and it died a quiet bureaucratic death.

So we returned to square one by appointing the Super Committee with a built-in recipe for failure.  Republican members had taken a pledge not to raise any taxes.  This is the Grover Norquist commitment – a promise made to an unelected lobbyist whom most Americans have still never heard of.  Many of the Republican committee members had also committed themselves to protecting defense spending.  Meanwhile, Democrats had largely foresworn major cuts to the entitlements associated with the nation’s major social agendas– principally the aforementioned Social Security and Medicare programs.  So between the hidebound positions of the two parties, there was little room for agreement from the outset.

Prior to the creation of the Super Committee, President Obama and House Speaker John Boehner had struggled unsuccessfully to reach a “grand bargain” that would have potentially reduced the national debt by some $4 trillion dollars over a ten-year period, but those controls would have included some tax increases.  Boehner held firm on the “no tax increases” position – even for Americans making a million dollars or more annually -- referring to those top earners as “job creators” and warning that taxing the wealthy would reduce their incentive to develop new opportunities for others.

Meanwhile, according to an LA Times report, a group of "patriotic" millionaires, led by Leo Hindery Jr., former chief executive of AT&T Broadband; Frank Jernigan, a former senior software engineer for Google Inc.; and Garrett Gruener, founder of Ask.com, lobbied the Super Committee this week to raise taxes on the super rich, saying, “Any super committee deal that does not include higher taxes for millionaires should be killed.”

Some millionaires have been falling all over themselves asking to be taxed more since Warren Buffett volunteered that he was under-taxed earlier this year and suggested that the tax code favored the wealthy over the middle class.  Though, to be fair, no one in this group has voluntarily written a check to the federal government as of yet.

Perhaps Buffett and his tax-volunteering millionaire friends should appoint themselves as the new Justice League of America, don traditional superhero tights and swoop in to save the Congressional Super Committee before it self-destructs just in time for Thanksgiving.  Because what this country needs right now is a dose of super heroism from its Super Committee instead of what we’re getting:  politics as usual.

IVP Existence Banner

Latest articles

Harry Kresky
Harry Kresky: An Independent Hero
The independent reform movement has lost a champion, but his work is sure to live on. Harry Kresky, ...
18 March, 2024
-
2 min read
Krist Novoselic
Smells Like Independent Spirit: Nirvana's Krist Novoselic and the Fight for Better Elections
Former presidential candidate and co-founder of the Forward Party Andrew Yang sat down with Nirvana co-founder Krist Novoselic, who went from changing the status quo in music to bringing that independent spirit to the political arena and the fight for better elections....
18 March, 2024
-
1 min read
vote
It's Time to Let All Voters Vote in South Dakota's Taxpayer-Funded Primaries
Unfortunately, the upcoming 2024 South Dakota primary election promises more of the same for our state....
15 March, 2024
-
5 min read
TikTok
TikTok Has No Place in the Two-Party Duopoly
The US House of Representatives voted 352-65 Wednesday in favor of a bill (HR 7521) that would ban TikTok, a social media app used by approximately 170 million Americans, if Chinese tech company ByteDance refuses to divest from it....
13 March, 2024
-
7 min read
make every vote count
Report: 6-in-10 New Voters Register Unaffiliated in States that Suppress Independent Voters
Mounting research continues to show the real truth behind independent voter suppression in several states across the US....
12 March, 2024
-
3 min read
voter at polls
17% More Votes Count Under Ranked Choice Voting, Study Finds
A new study analyzing all single-winner ranked choice voting (RCV) elections since 2004 reveals a significant increase in meaningful votes and representation in elections under RCV....
12 March, 2024
-
2 min read