E-Verify: a potential threat to California's agricultural economy

image
Author: Chris Hinyub
Published: 10 Aug, 2011
Updated: 13 Oct, 2022
3 min read

Opponents of a recently proposed House bill that cracks down on undocumented workers say that if it becomes law, it threatens to topple the agricultural economy of California – the nation's new breadbasket – risking the food and financial security of millions of Americans.

 

The last time the numbers were compiled, California continued its reign as the largest agricultural producer and exporter in the nation, benefiting mostly from its fertile Central Valley region. In 2009, state farmers brought in roughly 35 billion in revenue, and supplied the nation with half of all U.S.-grown fruits, nuts and vegetables. Several crops regularly purchased throughout the country and exported overseas are grown solely in the Golden State.  However, the realities of nature and the laws of thermodynamics dictate how, in order to benefit so many, the Valley's bountiful harvest must be won: it requires the manual labor of hundreds of thousands of “foreign guest workers.”

 

IVP Donate

Its no secret that illegal immigrants are the lifeblood of conventional farming operations in California. Unlike grain-laden Midwestern farms, most of California's 81,500 growers produce specialty crops, stone fruits and fragile commodities that don't take well to mechanized harvesting. Without a large and cheap labor force, these foods won't make it out of fields, much less into your kitchen. At least, this is the matter-of-fact argument provided by agricultural opponents of E-Verify – a federal database employers use to validate the legal status of their would-be employees.

 

State agricultural leaders have been frantic in their opposition to a bill introduced in June by Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Texas) that would force California farmers to use the E-Verify system to check out all potential hires. Their stance, and that of the California Farm Bureau Federation is that if the bill can't be defeated, it must be amended to accommodate the unique circumstances of California's food system. It is the only way to keep it from collapsing, they say.

 

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

House conservatives have found traction with the measure among their base, which appears to be especially reactionary during this time of high unemployment. Proponents argue that undocumented workers are taking away jobs that should go to Americans first.

 

But that's the solution, not the problem says Bryan Little, CFBF director of labor affairs.

 

     "There is not another labor force out there for our industry other than the one we have now. And taking that away will create huge problems," he said.

 

More Choice for San Diego

The unfortunate fact remains that Americans don't seem to want to farm, at least not in the “traditional” sense. Valley farmers are thus caught in a dangerous place. Those who fear running afoul the law say they try to use the federal government's current guest agricultural worker program, but its mandates make recruiting a necessarily large number of workers within the narrow window of time a farmer has to accurately predict the size of his harvest, an impossibility. Others simply ignore the laws, content with harboring one of America's largest illegal labor forces.

 

Then there are the labor advocates. The only sensible fix for them, as well as for devotees of William of Ockham's philosophical legacy, is to legalize workers en masse.

 

IVP Donate

As an instance of immigration reform, Smith's bill faces a dubitable future considering the Senate's standoffish attitude towards that subject. Still, it does make us confront a critical question: if farmers can't find enough documented workers to tend livestock and harvest crops, and if undocumented workers aren't their to pick up the slack, will California's economy and perhaps that of the nation be dramatically altered?

Latest articles

Cartoon image of Cuomo and Adams running into each other with cars.
Adams and Cuomo Power Players Play Chicken With New York Elections
NYC Mayor Eric Adams and former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo are currently playing a game of chicken with each other – leveraging the city’s electoral system to pressure the other to quit the race. The question is: Who will blink first? Or… are they headed for a collision?...
14 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
Open Primary NYC
5 Influential Forces in NYC that Threaten the Success of Open Primaries
New York City’s Charter Revision Commission (CRC) is considering a proposal to adopt a nonpartisan “Top Two” open primary system, which would allow the city’s 1.1 million independent voters to cast a ballot in primary elections they pay for....
14 Jul, 2025
-
13 min read
Tyson points at Trump with a marijuana leaf behind him.
Mike Tyson Calls Out Donald Trump to Make Good on Cannabis Rescheduling Promise
Mike Tyson, the former heavyweight boxing champion known as “Iron Mike,” is calling on President Donald Trump to make good on a campaign promise to reclassify cannabis under federal law....
11 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read