Bad economy could delay implementation of California's global warming bill

image
Author: Alan Markow
Published: 31 Mar, 2010
Updated: 13 Oct, 2022
2 min read

California’s effort to fight global warming may be caught on the horns of a dilemma.  While the state (and especially Governor Schwarzenegger) wants to lead the nation in all things green, the matter of poor economic conditions and high unemployment has become an unexpected roadblock.


Big Oil is all over the problem, wishing no harm to the environment but seeking only to protect unemployed Californians by canning the entire bill.  Schwarzenegger opened the door to their entreaties recently by announcing a “go slow” approach to implementation of AB 32.  But Calbuzz noted in a recent blog that Big Oil may well be underestimating the disdain of the California electorate for all things crude, and overestimating the value of short memories when it comes to such issues as the Enron debacle.  As Calbuzz states, once Californians understand that oil money is backing the “no on AB32” campaign, they’ll turn “yes” in a droves.


Is there a definitive answer to the question of whether environmental activism is good or bad for California and the nation?

The left-leaning Seminal website reports a resounding vote for “good” based on a March 29 report from the California Air Resources Board (ARB).   This new report was prepared in response to criticism that ARB’s earlier positive report on AB32 was too optimistic.  The just-released report states that AB32 will actually grow California’s economy by nearly one percent annually.


“This analysis confirms what economists have been saying all along: that full implementation of the Scoping Plan is the right choice for California to make an affordable transition to a clean energy economy,” said ARB Chairman Mary D. Nichols in an agency news release. “It supports continued economic growth and sets us on a course for greater energy security and less dependence on petroleum.”


Criticism of the earlier report is summarized here by the right leaning NC (Nevada Citizens) Media Watch.


So what’s a Californian to believe? 

CA State Senator Fran Pavley says that many of the bill’s opponents have a case of "Chicken Littleism", and argues that there’s more at stake if we fail to implement AB32.  “It makes no sense to introduce an initiative that would halt economic development and the energy we need to reduce our dependence on foreign sources of fuel and energy,” she wrote for the California Weekly website.  And she lists a series of statistics that show the thousands of jobs enabled by the state’s green legislation.


The U.S. Chamber of Commerce opposes the legislation, but California Chamber spokeswoman Denise Davis said, “Our position is not the same as the US Chamber” in a November, 2009 Capitol Weekly article.

IVP Donate


AB32 is the kind of legislation that deserves plenty of attention from the California electorate, but may not receive it as long as jobs are at the top of people’s minds.  Yet, it’s the connection with future jobs and the development of new green businesses that are at stake.


What’s your opinion?

Latest articles

Cartoon image of Cuomo and Adams running into each other with cars.
Adams and Cuomo Power Players Play Chicken With New York Elections
NYC Mayor Eric Adams and former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo are currently playing a game of chicken with each other – leveraging the city’s electoral system to pressure the other to quit the race. The question is: Who will blink first? Or… are they headed for a collision?...
14 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
Open Primary NYC
5 Influential Forces in NYC that Threaten the Success of Open Primaries
New York City’s Charter Revision Commission (CRC) is considering a proposal to adopt a nonpartisan “Top Two” open primary system, which would allow the city’s 1.1 million independent voters to cast a ballot in primary elections they pay for....
14 Jul, 2025
-
13 min read
Tyson points at Trump with a marijuana leaf behind him.
Mike Tyson Calls Out Donald Trump to Make Good on Cannabis Rescheduling Promise
Mike Tyson, the former heavyweight boxing champion known as “Iron Mike,” is calling on President Donald Trump to make good on a campaign promise to reclassify cannabis under federal law....
11 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read