Knives Come Out Against Reform at NYC CRC Hearing as Independents Rise

Picture of skyscraper in New York behind a bridge.
Photo by Anita Austvika on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by IVN Editor Shawn Griffiths.
Published: 30 Jun, 2025
Updated: 01 Jul, 2025
3 min read

NEW YORK CITY - Last week in Staten Island, the NYC Charter Revision Commission held its next-to-last public hearing. As Commissioner Diane Savino commented, addressing NYC's closed primary system “is the single biggest issue we’ve heard this year.”

The hearing was a clash between establishment opponents of reform (who have been hiding behind the age-old tactics of “more study needed” and “unintended consequences" since 1998!) and independent leaders and voters who are urging the Commission to let a million independents fully participate.

You get a great sense of “let us vote vs. we need more time to study” tension in an interchange between Cathy Stewart, National Organizing Director at Open Primaries and an advocate for primary reform in NYC for over 20 years, and Susan Lerner, the Executive Director of Common Cause NY, who urged the commission to take a pass.

And earlier in the week, dozens of NYC unions penned an open letter to the commission claiming that letting one million independent voters (50% of whom are people of color) participate in primaries would “reduce the life chances of working-class Black people and other working-class people of color.”  

Letting more people of color vote hurts…. people of color?  

Commissioner Buery addressed the naysayers by remarking that “we know this issue has already been considered by numerous Charter Revision Commissions over the years. It's actually been put on the ballot before."

There is also a risk that you could take more time and never have a Commission that’s willing to put this on the ballot again. I think there are risks in every process. I do think this is on our agenda not by design but because we heard tons of people who want it on our agenda, it would seem disrespectful not to consider those voters.”

Other highlights:  

IVP Donate

  • Deborah Green from Queens spoke about her experience as an independent forced to reregister into the Democratic Party to cast a meaningful vote. She quoted from the Manhattan Institute’s Issue Brief, New York City Voters Have an Appetite for Electoral Reform Polling and AnalysisTheir polling found that 23% of registered Democrats cite their main reason for affiliating with the Democratic Party was in order to vote in the primary. This number doubled from 2024.  
  • David Cherry, Open Primaries Board Member and President of the Leader’s Network in Chicago, spoke about his experience growing up in NY where independents are barred from voting in primaries and moving to Chicago with a nonpartisan system. David shared, “This system doesn’t automatically solve all of our problems. We still have to fight and advocate for the issues we care about. But the important thing it does is allow new opportunities to create new coalitions with new people.”  Commissioner DaBaron picked up on David’s testimony and said, “I just want to highlight one thing which I made a note of which is that idea of new coalitions with new people. That really stands out to me.”
  • Eric Bronner from Veterans for All Voters talked about the number of veterans in NYC who are independents (65,000) and his experience in St. Louis in passing a nonpartisan primary system with approval voting. Under the new system, passed in 2020 by the voters of St. Louis, the city elected its first African American woman as mayor, and the first woman elected as president of the Board of Aldermen. 

The Commission has one final hearing in Harlem on July 7. Don’t miss your chance to weigh in. You can find out more about testifying by emailing Cathy Stewart at cstewart@openprimaries.org. Take a moment and add your name to the Letter to the Charter Revision Commission and share it with your friends and family.

 

Editor's Note: This piece originally appeared in the Open Primaries weekly newsletter, "Primary Buzz," on June 27, 2025, and has been edited for publication on IVN.

Related articles

state of Louisiana with a closed stamp over it.
Louisiana’s New Voting System: Closed, Confusing, and Costly
Louisiana is making the switch to closed partisan primaries for some elections in 2026, using a syst...
30 Jul, 2025
-
6 min read
Stop light with the capitol building in the background.
DC Dems to Independent Voters: You Don’t Matter
The DC City Council had one final opportunity to fund a provision approved by 73% of city voters in November that would open primary elections to 83,000+ independent voters – and the Democratic-controlled body elected instead not to honor the will of voters....
29 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
Michael Smerconish
Michael Smerconish Leads Lawsuit Against Both Political Parties
CNN host Michael Smerconish is a Pennsylvania voter who is denied access to taxpayer-funded primaries because he is a registered non-party affiliate (independent). He is also one of the plaintiffs in a new lawsuit challenging his state’s use of closed primaries. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
1 min read

Latest articles

House of Cards logo in front of Texas Capitol
Texas Redistricting Drama Turns into 'House of Cards' Episode
As Texas Republicans push forward with a controversial plan to redraw the state’s congressional districts, Democrats are weighing whether to deploy one of their most extreme forms of resistance: a quorum break....
31 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read
US Capitol Building with American Flags in front.
Five Seats, One Revolution: Independents Launch Political Disruptor
One week after hosting its inaugural event in DC, the founders of The Independent Center announced the formation of the Independent PAC, a hybrid political action committee designed to do one thing: deny the two major parties a majority in Congress....
31 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
state of Louisiana with a closed stamp over it.
Louisiana’s New Voting System: Closed, Confusing, and Costly
Louisiana is making the switch to closed partisan primaries for some elections in 2026, using a syst...
30 Jul, 2025
-
6 min read