9/11’s Legacy: How It Changed America’s War, Culture, and Law

On September 11th, the US remembers its fallen citizens, murdered in the worst terrorist attack since the Oklahoma City bombing.

In unison, they #neverforget the 3,000 people who were murdered that day. But, people have forgotten so much — or have never known — 16 years later, how 9/11 has effected US war, culture, and law.

US citizens did what its founder, Ben Franklin, warned never to do — they exchanged freedom for security.

War

9/11 was followed by an intense national campaign to expand presidential military powers, in order to protect the US from terrorism.

The Iraq War, which started with an alarming pre-emptive carpet bombing, under false pretenses, was one of the immediate consequences.

Pre-emptive war is considered illegal under international law, but became a US strategy after 9/11, threatening other countries since, like Iran and North Korea.

US citizens did what its founder, Ben Franklin, warned never to do -- exchange freedom for security.
Kathryn Bullington, IVN Independent Author

The US was infamously willing to ‘go it alone’ in Iraq, against the international community. Today, echoes of US isolationism remain, with frequent challenges to the UN and NATO as legitimate factors in US policies.

After 9/11, the US used torture, and unmanned drones, under seemingly endless executive military power.

These tactics plague the US’s image, and erode the nation’s moral authority around the globe.

Collectively, changes in ways in which the US runs its war efforts after September 11th have greatly expanded executive powers to unilaterally and aggressively carry out its military agenda, under a constant impending threat of terrorism.

Civilian deaths in the US’s wars on terror have ballooned to over 1 million, according to a report authored in partnership with Physicians for Social Responsibility, and show no signs of stopping.

Laws

Several post 9/11 laws have enabled the executive branch to not only target foreigners with overarching new powers, but also the American people.

Since 2001, laws authorized under the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), specifically the Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF), have given the executive branch its expanded military powers to target anyone or anything it can connect to ‘terrorism.’

Subtitle D of the NDAA allows for indefinite detention of US citizens suspected of connections with terrorism, without due process.

Several post 9/11 laws have enabled the executive branch to not only target foreigners with overarching new powers, but also the American people.
Kathryn Bullington, IVN Independent Author

The Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001 (US Patriot Act), passed with remarkable speed after 9/11. It gave the executive branch its confidence to use broad powers to interpret who or what might be labeled a ‘terrorist,’ foreign or domestic.

The Patriot Act is aided by the FISA Amendment Act of 2008, which gave immunity to companies that comply with government requests for the people’s information.

The USA Freedom Act, passed in 2015, reined in some of the abuses, but there is still a long way to go to restore legal integrity of US citizens’ constitutional rights, according to civil liberty groups like the EFF and ACLU.

Laws enacted as emergency responses to 9/11 have significantly eroded First and Fourth Amendment rights to free speech, freedom of association, privacy, and due process.

Culture

None of these changes could have taken place without a significant change in culture.

Fear was not just a natural phenomenon, as a response to the unimaginable sight of the Twin Towers cascading in free fall in the middle of New York City. It was sustained by the Bush Administration, which vilified dissent, reminded US citizens of their insecurity daily, and instituted a super-patriotism that pulses through America still.

“If you’re not with us, you’re against us” became America’s new slogan. It did not only apply to foreigners, it applied to anyone who criticized the Bush administration, and specifically, the War on Terror.

Those who criticized the Bush administration were increasing called ‘un-American’ and ‘with the terrorists,’ climaxing in Michele Bachmann’s calls, in 2008, for an inquiry into ‘liberal’ Congress members who might hold ‘un-American’ views.

Widespread acceptance of Islamaphobia made it easy to target others -- liberals, Black Lives Matter, immigrants, and yes, this game has circled back to target conservatives.
Kathryn Bullington, IVN Independent Author

If you were politically aware around 2001, you might remember American flags everywhere, from the new Fox News logo, to its ubiquitous use in advertising. It was the visual precursor to the chants of “USA! USA!” we hear in populist crowds all over the country.

Muslims have taken the brunt of abuses from overarching government authority; and shifting cultural views of what it means to be American, and who the ‘enemy’ is.

Widespread acceptance of Islamaphobia made it easy to target others — liberals, Black Lives Matter, immigrants, and yes, this game has circled back to target conservatives.

It’s no wonder that Americans of all sorts feel threatened, and need protection against some ‘enemy.’

But, who is the ‘enemy’? Islamic terrorists who “hate freedom,” or fellow citizens willing to sacrifice each other’s freedoms for “protection”?

Whose freedoms are being sacrificed? Protection against what? The answers are not clear.

A Nation of Fear

Immediately after 9/11, 60% of Americans in a Pew Research poll were OK with trading civil liberties for security, under the threat of terrorism. That number bounces up and down depending on how fearful the public is:
Public's shifting concerns on security and civil liberties
America has been a culture of fear since 9/11. In such a whirlwind — trying to protect itself against an always imminent, un-American terror — that delineating ‘who is us and who is them,’ and ‘what is American,‘ has proved illusive.

If you question how we got here, answers can be found by reflecting on how September 11, 2001 changed US war, laws, and culture.