logo

A Taxing Problem

image
Author: Mytheos Holt
Created: 08 January, 2009
Updated: 13 October, 2022
3 min read

In the aftermath of the release of Gov. Schwarzenegger's proposed budget, he has found himself blocked by an unlikely source.

The Los Angeles Times reports that Schwarzenegger's plan has received most of its opposition from California's Republicans, rather than by Democrats, who are now using the Republican opposition to the budget as an excuse to remain ambivalent. Most of the opposition comes from assembly minority leader Mike Villines, who has stated point-blank that, "Republicans cannot support the governor's proposal to impose $14 billion in higher taxes on Californians."

Any enemy of overweening government would concede that Villines has a point. Given that tax cuts have proven to be such a winning issue for Republicans and Schwarzenegger has until recently proven to be such a losing governor where principled leadership is concerned, it's no surprise that Villines wants to cut him loose.

When the backlash against Schwarzenegger's badly marketed, Scrooge-esque leadership inevitably happens, Villines is poising himself and his fellow Republicans to protest that Schwarzenegger wasn't one of them, and didn't speak for their party. The real route to economic recovery is always through tax cuts, this hypothetical Republican apologia would run.

Politically, this is smart. Economically, it is dubious. While the cause of cutting taxes is almost always philosophically and morally justified because it clips the wings of government before tyranny can take flight, it is difficult to argue that it is always economically justified.

The infamous Laffer Curve, which demonstrates how tax revenue can increase when tax rates are decreased has been proven historically correct, but even a simple look at the curve will prove that the optimal tax rate is never zero. This suggests that even according to this supposed bulwark of supply-side economics, there is such a thing as having tax rates that are too low. Naturally, there is room for disagreement over whether California's tax rates are too low, but it seems indisputable that regarding the variables the Laffer Curve is supposed to measure - namely, the effect of the tax rate on revenue - the tax rate is in the wrong place.

This does not necessarily argue for a tax increase, but it doesn't argue against it either. Villines belongs to a breed of Republicans whose favorite pastime is to starve the beast of government, and while this is a noble goal, if the beast is gnawing off its own leg, one has to realize that starving it any further is probably an exercise in futility.

Villines is taking a rather large gamble by sticking to his guns like this - he appears to either be betting that Schwarzenegger will come up with a more reasonable compromise by February, or following in the footsteps of Newt Gingrich by whistling happily as he careens down the road to a government shutdown.

If such a shutdown were to occur, it is not clear whether Villines could lay the blame at Schwarzenegger's feet. The governor is above all else a political survivor, and would be sure to throw this belligerent assembly leader under the bus. The danger in this is that if Schwarzenegger were to leave Villines with the blame for a government shutdown, it would forever taint the cause of tax cuts with extremism, thus knocking out yet another principled cause against the state. Discretion is the better part of valor, and Villines ought to be more cautious before declaring Schwarzenegger's plan to be an attack on the better part of California's income.

Latest articles

votes
Wyoming Purges Nearly 30% of Its Voters from Registration Rolls
It is not uncommon for a state to clean out its voter rolls every couple of years -- especially to r...
27 March, 2024
-
1 min read
ballot box
The Next Big Win in Better Election Reform Could Come Where Voters Least Expect
Idaho isn't a state that gets much attention when people talk about politics in the US. However, this could change in 2024 if Idahoans for Open Primaries and their allies are successful with their proposed initiative....
21 March, 2024
-
3 min read
Courts
Why Do We Accept Partisanship in Judicial Elections?
The AP headline reads, "Ohio primary: Open seat on state supreme court could flip partisan control." This immediately should raise a red flag for voters, and not because of who may benefit but over a question too often ignored....
19 March, 2024
-
9 min read
Nick Troiano
Virtual Discussion: The Primary Solution with Unite America's Nick Troiano
In the latest virtual discussion from Open Primaries, the group's president, John Opdycke, sat down ...
19 March, 2024
-
1 min read
Sinema
Sinema's Exit Could Be Bad News for Democrats -- Here's Why
To many, the 2024 presidential primary has been like the movie Titanic - overly long and ending in a disaster we all saw coming from the start. After months of campaigning and five televised primary debates, Americans are now faced with a rematch between two candidates polling shows a majority of them didn’t want....
19 March, 2024
-
7 min read