Why the United States is Exceptional
By Lucas Eaves on 08/20/2012 in American exceptionalism, exceptionalism, foreign affairs with 18 CommentsRead Time: 4 - 6 minutes
The United States is exceptional, but not for the reasons you may think.
It has been a year since I arrived in the United States and I thought it was time to make a summary of my impressions about this country. Americans pride themselves in their “American exceptionalism”. And I agree with that statement: the United States is “unusual, not typical” to take the Oxford dictionary definition of “exceptional”. But I don’t believe it is true because of the reasons usually advanced. I believe the United States is exceptional for their capacity to embody everything and its opposite and to an extent that I have not seen before. America is the country of the extremes, something that has baffled me more than once during this past year. And the recent “legitimate rape” scandal is just a reminder to the world that the United States is capable of the best, but also the worst.
Here is a short list of reasons the United States is exceptional under my definition:
- It is a country that was one of the first western countries to legalize abortion broadly, but today is subject to a growing number of restrictions in numerous states.
- It is a country capable of sending a robot to Mars to study the habitability of the planet, but also has 40% of the population believing that man was made in its actual form by God 6,000 years ago.
- It is a country that has only one state with less than 20% obesity, and an average of 30% obesity nationwide, but is still able to win more medals than any other country in the 2012 Olympics.
- It is a country that until recently was the biggest polluter in the world (now ranked second), but in which 46% of American deny that human activity is the reason for global warming.
- It is a country that has more nobel prizes than any other country, but whose Congress recently passed a law declaring tomato sauce on pizza a vegetable.
- It is a country where the bottom 50% of Americans own 1% of the country’s wealth, while the top 1% owns 34.5% of it.
- It is a country that produces more porn than any other country in the world, but where most Hollywood actresses need to wear a bra while having sex.
- It is a country where within a one hundred mile radius, you can find both German baptist farmers who live a very ascetic lifestyle in the California Central Valley and clothes optional, hippie-style student cooperatives on the Berkeley campus.
- It is a country that holds the title of “World Most Powerful” country, but where you have a disproportionate number of presidential candidates that have no clue of foreign affairs.
- It is a country where you can drive at 16, vote, die for your country, and get a medical marijuana license at 18, but can only enjoy a cold beer when you are 21 (and with the exception of a few Muslim countries, the U.S. is the only country with such an age limit).
These are just a few highlights of extremes I have found while in the U.S., and I intentionally did not research the deeper reasons for each of these phenomenons, as my intention is to paint a general picture of how the United States can appear to an alien.
I will conclude by saying that I believe that the United States has the potential to do the worst and the best like no other country I have visited, and because of all the people that I have personally met, I trust that the U.S. can remain a source of greatness.






Leave Your Comment →
18 Comments
Byron DeLear
08.20.2012
@bdelear
Good piece! Funny and so true — a land of extremes, and the state of extremes would have to be California..
JTrott
08.20.2012
@JTrott
I’ve noticed some Americans will readily offer a joking canard that the French are cowards. (It’s doubtful any of them have heard of names like Jean Moulin.)
I think there is an underlying envy because they can’t speak French.
Janet Lynn
08.20.2012
Oh you folks are going to be in DEEP you know what with the Obama Dems. They don;t think this country is exceptional.
Jose Ortiz
08.20.2012
That this country has excited for over 200 years is exceptional.
Chad Chilstrom
08.20.2012
more people locked up in cages than the rest of the world combined…
Jane Payne
08.20.2012
because we get away with ALL war crimes.
Ariel H Fradin
08.20.2012
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JM3nvATF-U8
Ariel H Fradin
08.20.2012
It’s not just “Obama Dems,” sweetie: it’s anyone who’s paying attention.
By refusing to recognize our failures, we doom ourselves to defeat as we pat ourselves on the back for past successes while the rest of the world passes us by in most arenas that aren’t either athleticism or military strength.
Ben Marcus
08.20.2012
I believe the proper phrase here is, “Hate, hate, hate, hate, hate.”
Greg Hall
08.20.2012
I think the point is, like the reality of the ying & yang of the universe, the U.S. has it’s high points and low points. Let’s just take one example, although I could give you hundreds. The United States is the most charitable country on the planet, and yet, hunger is still a problem here. The U.S. is not the best at everything and it’s not the worst at everything either. The haters that think we are the worst, are no better than the delusional people who think we are the best.
Dennis Shaffner
08.20.2012
We have artists producing original work with population buying $29.95 sofa sized imports!
Nicole J Hyke-Cintron
08.20.2012
Once we throw out all of those in congress who calls fruits vegetable we will certainly know that the people who voted for them out are smarter…..
Nicole J Hyke-Cintron
08.20.2012
Vegetables that is
Jimmy Rose
08.21.2012
And how about all those gas guzzling automobiles no cars that are cheap on gas no sir. Wars on and on prisons everywhere “WINNING”.
Todd Vickers
08.21.2012
Great article.
Ron Cram
08.21.2012
When Congress passes laws like the one declaring tomato sauce a vegetable, then we need to decriminalize contempt of Congress.
Sarge Lintecum
08.21.2012
We vote for two parties when there is really only one.
Robert Higgins
08.22.2012
since a tomato is actually a fruit..one more thing congress got wrong? LOL and I’m afraid they’d turn around and classify it as a smoothie..