That 9/11 Speech Carly Fiorina Hoped We Forgot About May Kill Her Candidacy

image
Author: David Yee
Created: 11 Aug, 2015
Updated: 16 Oct, 2022
2 min read

In the wake of 9/11, Republican-hopeful Carly Fiorina, then CEO of Hewlett-Packard, delivered a speech titled, "Technology, Business, and Our Way of Life: What's Next?"

Like everything else right after 9/11, the attacks in New York and Washington dominated public discussion, and she opened her speech acknowledging the overwhelming impact the events had, as well as the cloud they casted even over her speech.

But Fiorina went one step further.

Closing her 3,700 word speech, Fiorina told the story of the spread of a civilization that she called "the greatest in the world."

This civilization spread, according to the speech, from Latin America to China, from northern climes to the tropics and deserts. This civilization was, of course, the original spread of Islam beginning 1,300 years ago.

Fiorina painted a very rosy picture of this spread, portraying it as both cosmopolitan, multi-cultural, scientific, and peaceful.

This, of course, is a very different view of Islam's history than most Americans are willing to accept. Most notably, most Americans are aware that almost two-thirds of all Christian nations fell to Islam's sword during this time period -- a time period that would eventually spark the European Crusades into the Middle East.

Fiorina and

Donald Trump are both facing the realities of what happens when people of business become politicians: every one of their past statements come under political scrutiny.

Trump has a solid advantage on this -- he just shrugs it off and says he doesn't care.

IVP Donate

Fiorina has a more difficult time with this -- if for no other reason than she's one of the ones under Trump's own critical microscope.

Our last three presidents -- Clinton, Bush, and Obama -- have all taken a very cautious approach toward the religion of Islam, all of whom have heaped praises on it as a peace-loving religion, and a freedom-loving people.

Bush and Obama have both bucked public opinion by doing this. Since 2001, a majority of Americans have viewed our fight in the Middle East as one against Islam itself, not radicals.

With the growing threat of the Islamic State dominating current foreign policy discussions and the prevailing view in the Republican Party that we need a stronger hand in the Middle East, it seems unlikely that there is much room for a candidate with the propensity to heap praises (even on past events) on our current enemies.

While religion -- or even outright bigotry against our enemies -- shouldn't be the issue, the longer these conflicts keep going, the harder it will be for politicians to buck the trends in American public opinion.

Speeches like Fiorina's will become political cannon fodder, used by her opponents to show that she's not in tune with the average American's opinions.

Like many other political skeletons, this speech -- though over a decade old -- may be what totally derails Fiorina's slim chances at advancing in the Republican primary.

Latest articles

AOC
Is Bernie Passing the Torch to AOC for the 2028 Presidential Election?
US Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) continues to make waves in US politics. She is co-headlining rallies across the country with US Sen. Bernie Sanders as part of the "Fighting Oligarchy Tour," which has drawn large crowds even in GOP strongholds....
17 Apr, 2025
-
4 min read
Oakland and San Francisco
Analysis: Popular Oakland Ranked Choice Voting System Used to Decide City's Next Mayor
On Tuesday, Oakland, CA used ranked choice voting (RCV) in special elections for mayor and City Council District 2 – marking Oakland’s 5th mayoral election using RCV. A 2024 poll found that 77% of Oakland voters are satisfied with the election method. ...
16 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
Someone putting on a i voted sticker.
Forward Party Launches New Mexico Chapter after Open Primaries Success
A new party launched Tuesday in New Mexico following the passage of open primaries legislation in the state. The Forward Party, which advocates for reforms like open primaries, is seeking 3,500 signatures to gain minor party status....
16 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read