The Media Gets Independent Voters Wrong -- And So Do Pollsters

image
Author: David Yee
Created: 08 Apr, 2015
Updated: 15 Oct, 2022
2 min read

A newly released Pew Research Center report once again shows that Americans who self-identify as independent remain near the 40-percent mark, but at the same time perpetuates the long-held stereotype that independents still fall only along red or blue lines and will vote in predictable patterns.

4-6-2015_01

The essence of this particular chart highlights the common belief that the independent voter is really just a leaning Republican or Democratic voter who just doesn't want to label themselves as a party member -- or doesn't want to share their true political beliefs with pollsters.

By their numbers, only a very small percentage of independent voters fall outside the political ilk of the major parties.

And there's definitely a large kernel of truth to this. Both 2012 and 2014 saw massive increases in straight-ticket voting, indicating an electorate that is becoming more polarized than ever.

Also, we just aren't seeing the number of successful independent campaigns we would expect to see if close to 40 percent of the electorate is truly independent.

Yet, countering all of this, we have hard data showing that voters are registering as independent or "no party preference" in record numbers.

For the 2014 midterm election, 23.1 percent of California's registered voters chose to register themselves as "No Party Preference."

Similar patterns are being seen across the nation. In at least 8 states, registered independents outnumber voters registered with the traditional parties.

IVP Donate

How can both of these concepts -- that there is no such thing as a "real" independent and the growing number of registered independents -- be true at the same time?

It's not like registering as an independent is without cost to the voter. In most states, registered independents cannot participate in the two-party primary process that determines who is on the ballot in the general election.

 

 

This is a huge price to pay for someone who is supposedly just a "left/right leaning" voter.

So what's missing from this paradigm?

What's missing is the refusal of the major media outlets to accept what it means to be an independent. This is the dialog we should be having:

OLAS Media

Right now, being independent in many states comes at a great cost: the inability to vote in an integral stage of the public election process; namely, the primary.

 

 

But as the independent movement gains strength and momentum nationwide, we will see that being independent isn't about being a leaning left/right voter... It's about changing the political system of the past hundred years that has created the entrenched, immutable partisanship we see in Washington today.

Photo Credit: Joe Belanger / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

Clear ballot box with ballot inside.
Skokie Is the Latest Illinois City to Embrace Ranked Choice Voting
Skokie voters went to the polls on April 1 amidst a closely watched mayoral election to decide whether or not to adopt ranked choice voting (RCV). With 100% of precincts reporting, 58% of participating voters said ‘Yes’ to changing how the city conducts elections. ...
02 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
Overhead shot of cargo at a port.
What Will Trump's 'Liberation Day' Mean for US Job Growth?
April 2 marks President Donald Trump’s ‘Liberation Day,’ which could usher in the most aggressive tariffs in modern US history or be completely blown out of proportion....
01 Apr, 2025
-
5 min read
Cory Booker
Cory Booker Just Delivered the Longest Senate Speech in US History
Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey made history with a marathon speech on the Senate floor, surpassing 24 hours in a sweeping protest against the policies of former President Donald Trump....
01 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read