For SCOTUS Rulings on Gay Marriage, It Isn't Always Black and White

gay marriage
Credit: Wikimedia Commons

The United States Supreme Court is expected to rule on the Defense of Marriage Act (Windsor v. United States) and California’s Proposition 8 (Hollingsworth v. Perry) in the next few days. There is a good possibility the decision on these two cases will be reserved for last.

The Washington Post offers an easy to follow graphic on the potential rulings and what the implications would be for each decision. It also provides status for marriage rights in each state. Check it out.

The Supreme Court can either uphold DOMA or they can strike it down as unconstitutional. If the justices decide the law is unconstitutional, federal benefits currently offered to heterosexual couples will be extended to homosexual couples in twelve states and the District of Columbia.

Hollingsworth v. Perry is not a black and white case. There are a number of different routes the high court can go with this case.

The Supreme Court could strike down Prop 8 and rule that a state cannot withdraw marriage rights to gay couples once those rights have already been offered. This decision would only affect California.

The justices could decide states cannot offer marriage benefits under a civil union, but withhold the label ‘marriage.’ This decision would have slightly broader implications as it would affect seven states.

California, Colorado, Hawaii, Nevada, Oregon, Illinois, and New Jersey currently allow same-sex couples to join in a civil union and can receive the same benefits a heterosexual married couple is eligible to receive, but the union cannot be legally labeled a marriage. If the high court rules a state cannot withhold the marriage label if they offer marriage benefits for civil unions, California is not the only state that will have to alter its laws.

More states will be affected if the Supreme Court rules Proposition 8 to be unconstitutional. If it the justices decide a state cannot deny same-sex couples the right to marry, it will impact marriage bans in 35 states. There are certainly regions in the United States where this decision would be extremely unpopular.

If the high court upholds Prop. 8 or decides it lacks standing, the only state affected is California. Obviously, if Prop. 8 is upheld, gay marriage will be banned in the state. If it is decided Prop. 8 lacks standing, same-sex marriage will continue in California and it could open the door for additional litigation challenging marriage bans nationwide.



The Independent Voter Network is dedicated to providing political analysis, unfiltered news, and rational commentary in an effort to elevate the level of our public discourse.

Learn More About IVN

Leave a Comment
Charlotte Dean
Charlotte Dean

So Doma is down, but who are the lawyers battling over prop 8 and what are their arguments? I'm fascinated to see how this plays out given the likelihood enough justices will acknowledge an inequality when they see one...but I'm also praying they don't sidestep the issue. I'll be interested to hear about the deliberation process post hearing because the justices are characters unto themselves...

Kaylan K.
Kaylan K.

I really look forward to seeing the outcome of these two cases. However, knowing SCOTUS, they'll find some way or another to not rule on gay marriage rights and instead focus on something tedious like jurisdictional issues.

Lucas Eaves
Lucas Eaves

I think they will strike down DOMA. For prop 8, i dont know.

Alex Gauthier
Alex Gauthier

the 'no take-backs' ruling seems a bit tenuous, either rights are guaranteed under the constitution or they aren't. I don't see how legally you can make the case that these people over here are subject to equal protection, but in this other state they aren't.

Bob Conner
Bob Conner

Nothing is ever straight forward or simple; is it?