Tim Donnelly Wants to Arm California Teachers
By Blake Bunch | 02/04/2013 | California, Headline, Issues, Legislation, News Ticker, Safety | 5 Comments
California Assemblymember Tim Donnelly (R-Twin Peaks) has introduced legislation to allow school districts to participate in a new school marshals program. This measure is one of nearly a dozen that have been introduced in the State Legislature in response to the outbreak of mass shootings this past year. Tweet
Donnelly seeks to expand the 1995 Gun Free Zone Act, a law that allows teachers to carry concealed weapons if their school district allows it. Assembly Bill 202, or the School Marshal Plan, will provide educators training in the use of firearms.
“In 1995, they obviously felt it was important to not deny that right to teachers who feel that need,” Donnelly said. “AB 202 just reiterates existing law.” Tweet quote: Tweet
AB 202 would also create a provision for school districts to pay for the weapons of qualified employees. The bill would further exempt these employees from the concealed-weapons-permit portion of California’s Open Records Act.
As stated in a previous IVN article, most of the proposed gun legislation currently deals with limits on ammunition and guns. Donnelly’s bill follows similar recommendations made by the NRA last month. However, in a Democratically-controlled Legislature, it is unlikely that this legislation will affect gun control in the state.
Citing the Sandy Hook Elementary School shootings at a press conference on Wednesday, Donnelly felt that lives could have been saved if someone had the ability to shoot back at the gunman.
“Your child is going to be locked in a school, and the only one with a gun is the person who came there to kill more kids than got killed in the last tragedy so he can get his name on television and go down in history in his own mind,” Donnelly said.
Legislation similar to AB 202 has already been rebuffed by Newtown Superintendent of Schools, Janet Robinson:
“I come from a military family. My dad was career military. My husband was a Navy pilot. We don’t keep guns. You know, I have great respect for guns. It takes a great deal of training for a police officer to shoot a weapon in action. Teachers are teachers, and if you think about elementary teachers, elementary teachers just love kids. They’re not gonna go packing and sit on the floor on the rug and read to the kids with a gun at their hip.” Tweet quote: Tweet
Some may argue that ammunition regulation will not end gun violence, but it is a step in the right direction for gun control measures. Perhaps arming teachers could help prevent a violent act, but many teachers and students could be uncomfortable with the idea of having firearms in the classroom





Leave Your Comment →
5 Comments
Alex Gauthier
02.04.2013
@alexg
its called the ‘Gun Free Zone Act’? Sounds like quite the opposite
Edward Bonnette
02.04.2013
@edwardbonnette
Sandy Hook was terrible, but is it really a good idea to have teachers bringing guns around little children on a daily basis? This just sounds like a huge accident waiting to happen.
Lucas Eaves
02.04.2013
@lucaseaves
Agreed. One moment of inattention and you can have a tragic accident. I don’t think teachers would want to take such a risk.
Ben Griffiths
02.04.2013
@ben_griffiths
Seems like we are at an impasse. We want children to be safe, but we don’t want guns to be in the same room with them? While these two concepts may seem incompatible to some, they are not.
I was held at gunpoint in a bank robbery at the age of 21. I wished someone had a gun to stop the man, as did the responding police officer who was shot as he pulled up.
The reality of today’s world is that you cannot protect yourself against a criminal unless you train and become proficient with a gun and carry it with you. Not because you want violence, but because you understand that criminal violence cannot be stopped unless someone who values peace is willing to wield the power of violence in defense of public and personal safety.
I have trained for hundreds of hours to become the type of person who can do so. Here are a couple basic ideas that I have learned that may help you to see the reality of the situation:
1. A gun is only useful for protection if it is loaded and accessible.
2. A loaded (useful) gun is only safe if it in a holster that is on your person. A holster covers the trigger guard and makes it impossible to pull the trigger by accident. In most cases people that wear holsters in public conceal them so that no one can see them.
3. In every case in our history (except 2) every school shooter has either immediately surrendered when confronted by force or immediately committed suicide – regardless of the qualifications of the person confronting them. (the 2 were revenge killings by adults, not normal school shootings)
4. We trust our teachers in a closed room with our children. We do background checks and certifications and trainings to make sure our children our safe with them. If we can’t trust teachers to defend our children, who can we trust?
I am not saying we should require all teachers to be armed. This is not a wise idea. But we are a nation willing to hire tens of thousands of Special Resource Officers (Police) in order to guarantee the security of our children. Why go to the expense when there are teachers at every school that are willing to volunteer to obtain the training and become designated school safety specialists? These teachers, if permitted by law (as they are in a number of states already) could obtain a license and training to be one of the armed responders for their school. The cost? Free. The only thing stopping these people from becoming a deterrent against school violence is antiquated laws and thinking. Have you ever read of a school shooting in Utah? Maybe those crazy armed teachers are onto something?
Debatepopular
05.10.2013
@debatepopular
I think it’s dangerous to have guns in an educational institution and what should be done is to provide security and this is not the best way.
I do not think that the responsibility of a teacher is to throw a bomb to a shooter.