Top 10 Bold Moves in American Foreign Policy
By Michael Higham | 07/29/2012 | Featured, War and Foreign Policy | 7 CommentsWhen we look at the history of American foreign policy decisions, it’s impossible to stick with only ten instances that pushed the envelope. Military operations are always bold and daunting considering the fact that lives will be at stake. For this compilation however, we focus on diplomatic episodes since the American Revolution. Without further adieu here are ten bold decisions in American foreign policy.
1. The Cuban Missile Crisis – President John F. Kennedy was faced with Soviet ballistic missiles being deployed in Cuba. Scholars have said that this incident was the closest the Cold War came to an full-scale war. Kennedy and his advisors worked on the best course of action. They went ahead with a blockade, formally “quarantine”, of Soviet ships transporting missiles.
2. The Suez Canal Crisis – Israel, France and Great Britain were in conflict with Egypt about the nationalization of the Suez Canal. President Eisenhower demanded a cease fire by placing sanctions on Great Britain and passing a cease-fire resolution in the United Nations.
3. The Monroe Doctrine – This was the declaration by President James Monroe in 1823 that prohibited European intervention in the Americas. Interference in the Americas would be recognized as an act of aggression. The doctrine has influenced America to become what it is today by leading toward expansionism.
4. The League of Nations – After World War I, President Woodrow Wilson’s bold plan for international cooperation was outlined in his “Fourteen Points”. Although the plan was never ratified by the United States, its ambition laid the groundwork for the United Nations.
5. Containment – This was the prevention of communism from spreading during the Cold War. Whether it be supporting non-communist governments or Although containment was an on-and-off policy, it was solidified by President Ronald Reagan and was maintained until the fall of the Berlin Wall.
6. Relief of Douglas MacArthur – President Harry Truman relieved General Douglas MacArthur of his duty in Korea in 1951. Truman and MacArthur were at odds with regards to a plan to fight the Korean War. This was an unpopular move on Truman’s part but the fact that he removed his most favored military officer is indeed a bold move.
7. Global War on Terror – GWoT, as it’s shortened, still exists today. We are familiar with Bush’s wars in the Middle East, but his decision to expand the War on Terror to Iraq in 2003 was a bold move. Bold does not exactly mean good. The War on Terror sees less support as it did when it began. See its implication everyday and it has shaped the United States role in the Middle East.
8. The Roosevelt Corollary, Big Stick Diplomacy – President Theodore Roosevelt derived his foreign policy approach from the Monroe Doctrine. He made it clear that the United States will intervene in conflicts between European and Latin nations. Some scholars make the connection to interventionist policies that followed the century.
9. The XYZ Affair – President John Adams and French diplomats were at a disagreement with status of their relationship. French leaders ordered American merchant ships to be seized and led to an undeclared naval war known as the Quasi-War. President Adams also declared the Alien and Sedition Acts during this time.
10. The Lend-Lease Act – Before the United States was an active combatant in World War II, President Franklin Roosevelt tried his best to stay out of the war. However, President Roosevelt supplied weapons for the Allies and ended his non-interventionist approach to the war with this act signed in March 1941. Nine months later, the United States would find itself fighting on two fronts on the largest war in history.
There is almost an infinite number of foreign policy decisions that have required politicians to stand strong. Yet, resiliency does not equate to a smart or sound decision. We’ve seen this in history, where a politician stands by a decision only to face the criticism for a lifetime. These ten events are just scratching the surface on tense and daring episodes of diplomacy.
Which event stands out to you as the boldest American foreign policy move?






Leave Your Comment →
7 Comments
Mewatis Montana
07.29.2012
When the foreigners thought the Constitution was the real thing without any respect for the people who inhabited North America.
Louie Goitz
07.29.2012
Going into Pakistan to get bin laden.
Tom McKeown
07.29.2012
Wondering if Bin Laden is really dead. We have no proof other than the words of the administration. The men who supposedly did the deed are sworn to secrecy for life and do so to protect their brothers in covert ops. The Pentagon is a puppet of the self proclaimed king and they all shiver in fear of Panetta and his boss. Gotta worry about that pension and book deal.
Tom McKeown
07.29.2012
Of those on the list, I’d say in my time The Cuban Missile crisis standdown. However who is to say that there are not missiles still there. The photo recon showed a dismantling but did not confirm removal. One that is missing is the decision by Nixon to resume large scale bombing of NVN to break the resolve of the NVN diplomats who were stalling progress in the Paris Peace talks. Sadly that was the only good result as we all know they violated the agreement and the most aggregious failure was to not reengage and destroy them. It resulted in the ravaging of any left in the South and signalled the world that we were in fact paper tigers when it came to our executive branch.
Dennis Shaffner
07.29.2012
How ’bout first catching up with the rest of the planet’s education record…then ask.
Jeff Mullen
07.29.2012
Well…if we don’t insist on proper morality, then there’s one that comes to mind. It was the work of Morals McKinley, who also gave us the Spanish American war–started on fraudulent pretenses, of course!
It seems that a right-wing junta calling itself “The Committee for Safety” marched into the royal palace in Hawaii and took the place over, at gunpoint. They forced the king to sign a “constitution” that encoded racism and rampant capitalist exploitation into the law. The terrorists won.
So…the next thing that they did was go over to the US and negotiate with good ol’ Morals McKinley. As you should guess, the fact that he was negotiating with terrorists didn’t phase ol’ Morals one bit! They were RICH terrorists–in fact, you may have heard some of their family names. “Dole” is one of them.
And that’s how Hawii became a U.S. Protectorate.
Oh…and if, like me, you saw footage of the big parades they had in Hawaii when you were in grammar school, now you can understand why. The “constitution” that the terrorists made the King sign was so bad for the natives that they celebrated getting rid of it–even if the United States Constitution wasn’t fully enforced, it was a huge improvement over what they had just to have ANY legal rights at all.
So, even though I don’t have much respect for good ol’ Morals, I have to say that he made a bold foreign policy move for the U.S. around the turn of the 20th Century.
I mean, if you’re going to put the bogus “War on Terror” on the list, why not this?
Faith Eischen
07.31.2012
@faitheischen
Yea definitely would include Pakistan…