logo

Arizona immunity case sheds light on privileged political class

image
Author: Chris Hinyub
Created: 12 January, 2012
Updated: 13 October, 2022
1 min read

Arizona Sen. Scott Bundgaard's alleged invocation of a state law, which gave him immunity to arrest last February when he was faced with misdemeanor domestic violence charges, has spawned legislation to amend a provision in the Arizona Constitution that grants partial immunity to lawmakers during and right before session.

Bundgaard resigned last Friday as a result of an ethics complaint filed by state Sen. Steve Gallardo. The former republican state senator from Peoria denied that he claimed legislative immunity. Several law enforcement officers who had responded to an altercation between Bundgaard and his then-girlfriend on the side of State Highway 51 testified before the Senate Ethics Committee that if Bundgaard had not claimed immunity, they would have arrested him on suspicion of domestic-violence assault. Officers did arrest Bundgaard's girlfriend.

Gallardo, however, means to make a further example out of Bundgaard. The Phoenix Democrat has proposed a resolution for a referendum that would let voters take aim at the immunity law. Senate Concurrent Resolution 1007 wants Arizonans to answer the question: why should lawmakers be exempt from arrest during session for all crimes except felonies, acts of treason or breach of the peace? If passed, the measure would keep in place legislators' immunities against civil court proceedings during and right before session.

The circumstances of Bundgaard's resignation were the impetus for another Gallardo bill. Senate Bill 1027 would require tougher fines and penalties for domestic violence offenders.

At a time when it's popular to cling to class warfare rhetoric, it will be interesting to see how much political capital there is to be gained from demagoguing the impropriety of seemingly archaic laws that elevate lawmakers to a class of their own.

Latest articles

voting
Breaking Down the Numbers: Independent Voter Suppression in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania held its primary elections Tuesday, which effectively acted as the general election in most cases. However, statewide, over a million voters had to sit on the sidelines because of the state's closed primary rules....
24 April, 2024
-
2 min read
Kennedy
DNC Loses Its First Attempt to Kick RFK Jr Off the Ballot
Independent presidential candidate Robert F Kennedy Jr will officially appear on the Hawaii ballot after a ruling Friday blocked an effort by the Democratic Party to disqualify him from ballot access. It marks the first loss by the DNC in its legal strategy to limit voters' choices on the 2024 presidential ballot....
22 April, 2024
-
3 min read
Asa Hutchinson
Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson Declares His Support for Ranked Choice Voting
In a recent episode of The Purple Principle, a podcast that examines democracy and polarization from a nonpartisan lens, former Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson said that while he was skeptical of ranked choice voting at first, he now sees it as a meaningful solution to elect candidates with the broadest appeal....
19 April, 2024
-
2 min read