Paid Advertisement

Although individual physicians practice all forms of specialized medicine, they have all learned the skills of defensive medicine to one degree or another. 

     “Defensive medicine can be simply defined as medical responses undertaken to avoid liability rather than to benefit the patient,” wrote Richard E. Andersen, M.D. in the Journal of Internal Medicine in 1999.

Dr. Andersen goes on to argue that this risk-averse behavior could be said to “violate the Hippocratic Oath, [do] violence to the doctor-patient relationship, and is manifestly self-serving for the physician.” But he then points out that standards of service have been adjusted to permit levels of tests and procedures that were once viewed as unnecessary.  The resultant increase in such procedures as caesarian deliveries and use of fetal heart monitors, Dr. Andersen argues, adds costs to the healthcare system, while providing very little additional protection to the patient.

According to some experts, costs associated with defensive medicine far exceed losses from malpractice cases, which tend to be a tiny part of overall health care expenses.  It is the threat of malpractice litigation that some believe has raised American health care costs to amounts that far exceed the rest of the world.

The conservative-leaning Washington Times reported back in 2009 that Harvard researcher Amitabh Chandra estimated the cost of defensive medicine at $60 billion annually.  “Other research places the yearly cost at roughly $200 billion,” the article stated without attribution.

According to a 2010 article by liberal-leaning NPR, Rep. Tom Price (R-GA) – a doctor himself – claimed on the Republican website America Speaks Out that the cost of defensive medicine runs $650 billion annually – nearly 25 percent of the nation’s entire healthcare bill.  But the NPR article then brings out its own Harvard health care cost expert who argues that most of the current cost estimates for defensive medicine are – in her words – “quite imaginative.”

She’s Michelle Mello of the Harvard School of Public Health, who performed a study for the scholarly publication Health Affairs in 2010.  She and her colleagues found that the total cost of medical malpractice-related expenses in the health care system, including defensive medicine, is about $55.6 billion per year, or about 2.4 percent of annual health care spending. Defensive medicine is about 80 percent of that total.

With numbers that swing from one extreme to the other, it’s wise for the average voter to consider the source of the information we try to grapple with as it pertains to an issue as complex as healthcare cost.  A friend of mine, who is a physician, got me started thinking beyond the limited cost of litigation and into the broader area of defensive medicine.  It made sense to me that there’s a lot more expense that goes into preventing litigation than there is in actual court cases, but the extreme high and low end claims in some of the source material seems politically motivated.  Amazingly, the two Harvard studies mentioned in separate articles from left and right-leaning publications reach nearly identical and relatively unsurprising conclusions. 

I also hear the echo of ambulance chasers whenever one of those BAD DRUG ads comes on the radio or television.  They make me believe that there are law firms out there trying to stir the pot just to make a profit for themselves, and I have to believe those firms are adding unnecessary costs to the healthcare system as well.

Join the discussion Please be relevant and respectful.

The Independent Voter Network is dedicated to providing political analysis, unfiltered news, and rational commentary in an effort to elevate the level of our public discourse.

Learn More About IVN

Leave a Comment
  1. zhuweiming1100 < coach outlet swarovski uk oakley sunglasses canada chanel handbags supra shoes cartier love bracelet prada shoes michael kors uk true religion jeans oakland raiders jerseys cheap soccer jerseys tommy hilfiger outlet minnesota vikings jerseys cheap nike shoes coach outlet canada koby bryant shoes nike roshe juicy couture outlet nike trainers mizuno running new york knicks jersey bottega veneta outlet kate spade outlet dallas cowboys jersey ralph lauren uk stuart weitzman boots coach outlet air jordan 13 chicago blackhawks jersey nike outlet store oakley sunglasses indianapolis colts jerseys san francisco 49ers jerseys mulberry outlet fivefingers shoes evening dresses cheap football shirts barcelona jersey nike huarache beats headphones chicago bulls jersey philadelphia eagles jerseys the north face outlet lebron james shoes nba jerseys michael kors uk real madrid jersey canada goose outlet dansko outlet mbt shoes pittsburgh steelers jersey kansas city chiefs jerseys nhl jerseys new england patriots jerseys chicago bears jerseys lebron james shoes nike free uk washington redskins jerseys the north face jackets baltimore ravens jerseys miami heat jersey los angeles lakers jerseys ysl outlet michael kors outlet uk boston celtics jersey seattle seahawks jerseys cheap wedding dresses the north face uk nike air max uk san antonio spurs jerseys vans shoes oklahoma city thunder jerseys atlanta falcons jersey gucci shoes new york jets jerseys chanel outlet hermes birkin new york giants jerseys arizona cardinals jerseys north face outlet los angeles clippers jerseys moncler coats christian louboutin uk nike running shoes the north face clearance tory burch outlet ray ban sunglasses air jordan shoes chelsea jersey custom mlb jerseys hermes outlet air max 90 michael kors outlet mulberry uk nike free north face jackets golden state warriors jerseys hermes belt air max 2015 ugg boots cleveland cavaliers jersey denver broncos jerseys air max 2014 futbol baratas miami dolphins jerseys burberry outlet nike free 5.0 tory burch outlet manchester united jersey the north face outlet store green bay packers jerseys soccer shoes new orleans saints jerseys ugg uk rolex watches uk zhuweiming0624