logo

Boxer ad draws ill-advised critique from Sacramento Bee

image
Author: Alan Markow
Created: 17 September, 2010
Updated: 13 October, 2022
3 min read

If the Boston Red Sox win the World Series, will it lessen their achievement if New York Yankee fans still don’t like them?  That seems to be the convoluted conclusion that the Sacramento Bee reached this week in critiquing an advertisement that touts what Barbara Boxer calls one of her top achievements. 

The subject of the ad is a new veterans’ combat care center that was constructed in California.  “It’s true,” says the Bee article, “that Boxer’s claim on veterans is generally accurate, but the ad doesn’t present the whole picture.”  Bee Washington Bureau reporter Rob Hotakainen then goes on to fill in the missing information: “…over the past decade [Boxer] has received marks of 50 percent or less from groups such as the Vietnam Veterans of America and the American Legion. 

What exactly does Boxer’s rating with two veterans’ group have to do with the accuracy of the ad?  Especially when you consider that the article also states, “Boxer received an A+ from the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America,  But Hatakainen wants Yankee fans (veterans’ groups that have never liked Boxer) to cheer for the Red Sox.  The article’s headline is also irrelevant to the accuracy of the ad:  “Some vet groups critical of Boxer.” 

This damning with feint praise approach to reporting is one of the reasons that the public is fast losing its confidence in the mainstream media.  They treat “balance” as important or possibly even more important as accuracy.  In fact, this article goes on to pull the same stunt on another aspect of the Boxer ad.  According to the article, the ad states that Boxer’s “after-school law is keeping a million kids off the street and out of gangs.” 

Hotakainen’s analysis? 

     “It’s true that Boxer teamed up with Republican Sen. John Ensign of Nevada to get the first major funding. This year, those programs receive more than $1.1 billion, serving 1.7 million children.  But Boxer engages in hyperbole by suggesting that all of those children would be on the streets or joining gangs if not for her efforts.” 

The ad never claims that all of the kids would have chosen the gang alternative without her program, but it does say that a million kids are off the street.  That in itself is a difficult-to-prove claim, albeit not unreasonable given that it’s just a little more than half of the kids receiving the services.  It is actually the Sac Bee that is engaging in hyperbole by trying to find something wrong with a clearly accurate ad by Boxer. 

This kind of press criticism of a positive, accurate ad about an incumbent’s record seems likely to drive the Boxer campaign back into negative advertising.  If the media is going to attack you for the right kind of advertising, you may as well start taking pot shots at your opponent.  You couldn’t be portrayed much worse than you are in this piece of lazy journalism. 

IVP Existence Banner

There’s no such thing as a political ad that doesn’t overreach.  But this Boxer ad seems about as accurate as you can get.  It should be praised for its honesty, not criticized for the sake of fairness or for some other, more nefarious motive.

Latest articles

votes
Wyoming Purges Nearly 30% of Its Voters from Registration Rolls
It is not uncommon for a state to clean out its voter rolls every couple of years -- especially to r...
27 March, 2024
-
1 min read
ballot box
The Next Big Win in Better Election Reform Could Come Where Voters Least Expect
Idaho isn't a state that gets much attention when people talk about politics in the US. However, this could change in 2024 if Idahoans for Open Primaries and their allies are successful with their proposed initiative....
21 March, 2024
-
3 min read
Courts
Why Do We Accept Partisanship in Judicial Elections?
The AP headline reads, "Ohio primary: Open seat on state supreme court could flip partisan control." This immediately should raise a red flag for voters, and not because of who may benefit but over a question too often ignored....
19 March, 2024
-
9 min read
Nick Troiano
Virtual Discussion: The Primary Solution with Unite America's Nick Troiano
In the latest virtual discussion from Open Primaries, the group's president, John Opdycke, sat down ...
19 March, 2024
-
1 min read
Sinema
Sinema's Exit Could Be Bad News for Democrats -- Here's Why
To many, the 2024 presidential primary has been like the movie Titanic - overly long and ending in a disaster we all saw coming from the start. After months of campaigning and five televised primary debates, Americans are now faced with a rematch between two candidates polling shows a majority of them didn’t want....
19 March, 2024
-
7 min read